Wednesday, June 15, 2016

Vote remain to sustain higher and further education in Wales

As a retired academic I would like to to make a special plea for people to support higher and further education by voting to remain.


During my career I was involved in teaching in both sectors, had responsibilities in a business school, and was involved in the funding of higher education in Wales. In addition I was a trade union activist throughout, at all levels of my union including a UK negotiator.


Over that period of time this sector of education became increasingly international. Not just in relation to students but totally in relation to research. All academic disciplines and knowledge are now international.


In Wales higher and further education is a major employer, it is the among the largest 'industry’ and in many of our towns, makes a major contribution to new high value industries as well as being a world leader in key areas of research.


Being part of the EU has enabled the UK to play a full role in this process. Wales, as the rest of the UK, is highly integrated into systems of student and staff exchange, like ERASMUS. Overseas student income basically keeps many of our Welsh universities going.

Possibly even more significant is the E70bn EU 2014-20 research fund, one of the largest single projects of the EU, which integrates research endeavour across the EU and which in many areas, universities in Wales and the rest of the UK take the lead. Consequently, our universities draw down a significant part of this fund running at £836m alone in 2014-15. Outside the EU applications for this funding and to the European Research Council will become very difficult and UK universities will lose their leading role.


For higher and further education in Wales to continue to flourish for the sake of all of us, we have to be part of the EU.


Please don't allow our lead and this great potential to be put in jeopardy.



Tuesday, June 14, 2016

Overseas students and returning British citizens impact on UK migration

Overseas students and returning British citizens impact on UK migration

Len Arthur 14 June 2016

You may be surprised, as I was, when I first discovered that overseas students coming to the UK were considered as part of the migrant inflow figures. When I looked a bit deeper I also discovered that returning British citizens were also included in these figures.

Now this is not to argue that this shouldn’t happen. When counting something lines of definition have to be drawn somewhere and infinite graduations of meaning don’t help the maths. So this is not to suggest that the definition of who is a migrant is wrong or needs updating - though I think there may be a good case for this - it is just that raw data can look very different when seen from a qualitative view that social meanings do have graduations.

My surprise about both categories being included in the migrant definition was that I started out with a common assumption that migration meant someone from another country moving to another for a longish period of time for family or work reasons. Overseas students are in the UK to study for a defined period of time and make a major contribution to our education system, particularly universities, both in terms of income and intellectual input. If they go on to work here the UK reaps the benefit of this education. Again returning British citizens do not fall into the common assumption of a migrant being a person with citizenship of another country.

So, without making any changes in definition, it is possible to use current data to assess what impact it would have on the net migration figure to the UK, if we put to one side overseas students and British citizens as part of the migrant inflow to the UK.

First some basics. Migration to and from a country is assessed by taking account of total inflows and outflows over a period of time. The difference in the two figures is defined as net migration and tends to be the figure the debate homes in on ‘millions coming to the country’ etc.

Taking the 10 year period from 2006 to 2015, the latest information available, we have a total inflow figure of 5.770m coming to the UK. The total outflow figure is 3.478m making a total of net migration of 2.489m. This net figure is larger than if you do the calculation as adjustments were made following the 2011 census.

Now, of the total inflow figure of 5.770m 1.875m are overseas students, and 0.829m are returning British citizens. Adding the figures for overseas students and British citizens together we arrive at 2.704m for the 10 year period.

You can see where this is now going. If you follow the argument about putting to one side the categories of British citizens and overseas students we can set deduct the total of these two figures from the starting inflow figure of 5.770m. This results in a different inflow figure of 3.066m.
Using this adjusted inflow figure of 3,066m a different net migration figure can be arrived at. Total outflow of migrants from the UK over the same period is as quoted above 3.478m. Now the surprise, take this from the adjusted flow figure of 3,066m and the result is minus yes minus 0.412m.

Numbers are important in the arguments about migration but so is getting a human and qualitative understanding of what the figures mean. What these calculations indicate is that net migration to the UK is not what is commonly assumed either in numbers or in terms of people and we should be more critical of the case made by the right.

Hopefully, using existing data and not wild projections these calculations can help make the point.


Period covered is the ten years 2006 – 2015

Total net inflow of migrants                    5.770m
Inflow adjusted for BS+OS                     - 2.704m       
=3.066m
Minus total outflow                                -3.478m
Net flow of migrants to UK as result        - 0.412m



Monday, June 6, 2016

Taking back real control

Take back control – what a good idea.

Ukip won’t be please but I’ve been converted!

Starting with the

Nationalisation of...
The banks
The railways
Water, electricity and all the privatised public utilities
BT
Royal mail and the post office
Restrict media ownership to 15% of the market, democratise the BBC.
Bring all schools back into local authority control and abolish charitable status on public schools.
All land except personal dwelling houses
Cancel all PFI type contracts and all privatisations of the NHS
State support for all forms of cooperative start ups and succession takeovers
Of course the list should go on, but you get the drift.
And of course control and governance shared between workers, consumers and the state

Real democracy...
The European Parliament to have powers to initiate legislation and a veto of the decisions of the Council of Ministers and the ECB
The renegotiation of the Treaty of Lisbon to remove all neo liberal and anti social elements
British General election at least every three years
Abolition of the House of Lords
Power and resources returned to local authorities
Immediate introduction of the most representational form of proportional voting
The first ever British constitution based upon the European Convention of Human rights and establishing a republic and equal powers to devolved assemblies and parliaments

Democratic social emancipation...
Removal of anti trade union legislation and the establishment of the constitutional right to strike and to have collective recognition in all workplaces
The absolute right to be employed with at least a fair wage and all workers to have a legally enforceable negotiated contract
A progressive system of taxation which is aimed at redistribution so there is at least only a 1 to 3 ratio between lowest income household and the top

Well you can add to the list but this is taking back control with a real purpose: putting you and me in democratic control of the centres of power so we can invest for needs of people and the planet, not profit.

Oh, it isn’t what UKIP, the bosses and the Leavers mean – I thought so.

I’ll just have to vote remain and continue to join up with workers across Europe who support really taking back power.


Thursday, June 2, 2016

The European Left and Left Unity – what’s it all about?

The European Left and Left Unity – what’s it all about?

Len Arthur – LU Wales

Left Unity is an international political party. We are socialists as our aim is to end capitalism, and we recognise that we have to fight for this transformation at an international and national level; both are terrains of struggle and are interlinked. It is not possible to prioritize one over the other.

Our first step in taking this aim forward has been to join the Party of the European Left (EL) as an observer member. From the current year we have been sending two delegates to EL meetings and delegates will be attending the fifth congress in Berlin in December.

This article provides a brief overview of the EL, its politics, how it works and what it is like being a participant.

Background

The EL was formed in 2004 over two separate conferences first in Berlin then in Rome. Talks about establishing a radical left and green alliance had started in 1998 between communist, socialist and green parties from across Europe, in part influenced by changes in Russia and East Europe, the communist parties and the coming together of the European Social Forum.

The link to the founding document with the full aims follows but here is a key part which reflects closely those of Left Unity.

“Therefore we refer to the values and traditions of the socialist, communist and labour movement, of feminism, the feminist movement and gender equality, of the environmental movement and sustainable development, of peace and international solidarity, of human rights, humanism and antifascism, of progressive and liberal thinking, both nationally and internationally. We work together in the tradition of the struggles against capitalist exploitation, ecological destruction, political oppression and criminal wars, against fascism and dictatorship, in resistance to patriarchal domination and discrimination against "others".”


In the European Parliament the European Left Unity/Nordic Green Alliance (GUE/NGL) existed in various forms before the foundation of the EL, evolving from a Communist and Allies group and first using the GUE bit of the name from 1989. http://www.guengl.eu/group/history and from 1995 the NGA became part of the group.

Following the 2014 European Elections 52 MEPs are now part of this group, including 27 from parties of the European Left. The group includes Podemos and Sinn Fein and here is a full list:  http://www.guengl.eu/group/delegations 

The EL currently

Membership of the EL is currently made up of 32 parties covering 23 different European countries with another 15 parties under consideration for membership. Left Unity is one of these 32 member parties and the only one from the UK. We are ‘observer’ members which although we are defined as ‘consultants’ means that we have full participation rights, except at the level of the Council of Chairpersons.

Not all parties who a members of the EL are from countries that are part of the EU such as Turkey, Moldova and Belorussia. Here is a list of the parties but it is a little out of date:  http://www.european-left.org/about-el/member-parties.

Collective individual membership of the EL is around 500,000. There are considerable variations across countries so in the UK as Left Unity we have around 1250 members whereas the two EL affiliated parties in Spain have around 107,000. Individual membership figures are important as they indicate the number of activists across Europe that can be mobilised in campaigns, solidarity and struggles at the national and international level.

Political influence can in part be gauged through votes. In the national election taking place in 2014 - 15 EL parties had around 11m not including those for other parties in the GUE/NGL group of MEPs. In terms of direct action, in France, the CGT trade union which is closely allied to EL member the French Communist Party, is taking a leading role in the direct action against the proposed anti labour legislation and other austerity measures.

Theoretical developmen is coordinated through Transform which is funded by the various political research foundations of EL parties, such a the Rosa Luxemburg foundation in Germany. http://www.transform-network.net/home.html. Kate Hudson and Felicity Dowling of Left Unity have both had articles in recent Transform publications.

EL’s latest political statement from 2013

“For us, there is no question of waiting for the European Union to crumble, and for the monsters that could emerge from the rubble, nor of promoting nationalist solutions setting the peoples against one another. The European Left, which we represent, is internationalist and stands together in solidarity. We strive towards a socialist alternative, a civilisation freed from capitalism, exploitation, oppression and capitalist violence. Ours is a vision that guarantees not only a distribution of wealth that supports work and an advanced social and economic development model, but also democracy, equality, democratic and social rights for all European citizens.

It is to this end that we fight for a re-foundation of Europe, in other words, for a new definition of its objectives, policies and structures; an economic, productive, social and ecological model that is totally different, and that is based on solidarity, social justice and popular sovereignty.”


It is worthwhile reading through the statement as there is much to give heart to someone who supports the argument that another Europe is possible, especially when the organizational size and scope of the EL and the GUE/NGL is taken into account.

Within the European Parliament the GUE/NGL has taken positions and made proposals which go some way toward putting this political statement into action:


Next steps

A new political statement is currently under development heading toward the Berlin conference in December 2016.

As Left Unity we have been fully involved in the process of developing this statement and the action and campaigning priorities that will follow from it. I was one of the elected LU delegates to a recent meeting of the EL executive board in Porto toward the end of April. Here is the report of that meeting that I produced for LU. It provides what I would like to think is an insight into current policy and campaigning concerns of the EL as well as a ‘feel’ for how it all really works: http://chwithunedigcymru.blogspot.co.uk/2016/05/report-of-party-of-european-left.html.

Developing this political statement is not straightforward and the acceptance of the austerity programme by the Greek Syriza government was a defeat, having very serious consequences for the Greek people and on how, as socialists, we see a social transformation from capitalism taking place. The EL is prepared to have that debate but it is yet to take place.

Conclusion

We argue as Left Unity that ‘another Europe is possible’ and for a remain vote in the referendum. We argue that case whilst being very critical of the EU.  We don’t believe in pipe dreams or grand rhetoric but in working with socialists across Europe, taking real steps toward this aim. It is hoped that this article can help provide some confidence that this can and will happen.

Left Unity, being a member of the EL, is central to our argument.